What Florida Landlords Can Deduct From a Security Deposit (and What Is Just Wear and Tear)

The line between damage and normal wear and tear decides most Florida deposit disputes. Real examples and what to do about damage you find later

Once the deadlines are handled, the next fight is almost always the same: what can you actually deduct? Florida lets a landlord charge a tenant for damage, but not for normal wear and tear. The trouble is that the line between the two is not always obvious. Here is how to think about it. 

Normal wear and tear: not deductible 

Wear and tear is the ordinary aging that comes from someone living in a home. A small nail hole from hanging a picture is wear and tear. Scuff marks on a wall are wear and tear. These are the cost of doing business as a landlord, and you cannot charge for them. Florida’s statutes do not define the term, so where the line falls depends on the facts. 

Damage: deductible 

Damage is different. If a tenant punches a hole in the wall, you can deduct the repair. If a child colors an entire wall with a permanent marker, that is not wear and tear. If a pet chews through the baseboards, that is destruction, and replacing them is a valid deduction. Broken items count too: a ceiling fan a tenant broke, a dishwasher that failed because it was overloaded, a glass stovetop that was shattered. If it was broken through misuse rather than normal aging, it is generally deductible. 

Be descriptive, always 

Whatever you claim, describe it clearly. We see claims all the time that just say “damage to stove” or “damage to wall,” and the first question is: what damage? Is the glass top broken? Is a part missing? Vague claims invite disputes and can weaken your case. Specific claims hold up. 

What if you find damage after you have returned the deposit? 

It happens. Maybe you missed something, or you had to return the deposit on a technicality, and then you notice damage you never claimed. You are not out of options. You can file a lawsuit against the tenant for those damages. You will have to prove them, and depending on the item, you may need an expert witness to establish the amount and any depreciation. 

Depreciation matters 

You may not recover full replacement value for something that was not new. If a tenant breaks the glass top on a ten-year-old stove, an expert may value it well below the price of a brand-new one. That is normal. You can still recover something, just not always the full sticker price. 

Not sure if it is damage or wear and tear? Calarco Law will help you build a claim that holds up. 

Share