Your Guest Will Not Leave. That Is Not an Eviction

Eviction, unlawful detainer and ejectment are three different Florida cases. Here is how a property owner tells them apart before filing

A woman calls and says she needs an eviction. Her cousin came down for a one week vacation in March. It is September. He is in the back bedroom, his mail comes to the house now, and he has stopped answering when she asks when he is going home. She wants him out. She is right that she needs a court case. She is wrong about which one. 

In Florida, three different actions get called an eviction by almost everyone who needs one. They are not the same case. They are not in the same chapter of the statutes. They do not use the same paperwork and they do not ask the judge for the same thing. File the wrong one and you can be dismissed. Then you start again, months later, with the same person still in your property. 

Three doors, and only one of them is yours 

Door one is eviction, Chapter 83, Part II for residential property. There is a landlord. There is a tenant. There is a rental agreement, and rent was part of the deal. 

Door two is unlawful detainer, Chapter 82. Someone is living in your property who never paid you rent. There is no landlord-tenant relationship because there was never a rental arrangement to begin with. 

Door three is ejectment, Chapter 66. The person in your property is claiming they own part of it, or that they have some equitable interest in it. That is a different fight, and a bigger one. 

The door you walk through is not decided by how angry you are or how long the person has been there. It is decided by the nature of the relationship. Nothing else. 

Eviction: there was a landlord and there was a tenant 

This is the case most people know, and it is the one they picture when they say the word. A residential eviction under Chapter 83 assumes a rental agreement. It can be written. It can be oral. It can be a handshake and a Venmo every first of the month. What matters is that the arrangement included rent and that the person was living there as a tenant, not as a guest. 

If that describes your situation, the eviction path is the right one, and it has its own notice rules that have to be right before filing. We have covered those notices before. They only matter once you know you are in the right kind of case. 

Landlords, if you have a tenant, act like it. Do not try to shortcut into a faster-sounding case because you are tired of the situation. A judge will look at the relationship, not the label you put on the pleading. 

Unlawful detainer: they never paid you rent 

This is the case for the houseguest who moved in. The relative who came for a week and stayed for half a year. The adult child’s friend who needed a couch for a few nights. The ex-partner who never left after the breakup and never contributed a dollar. 

It is not an eviction, because they never paid you rent, and that difference matters to the court. Chapter 82 exists precisely for the person who is holding your property without any right to it and without ever having been a tenant. You are not asking the judge to end a lease. There is no lease. You are asking the judge to confirm you have the right to possession and to put the occupant out. 

This is a common mix-up for owners, and it is understandable. From the inside it feels identical to an eviction. But the case you file has to match the facts, not the feeling. 

Ejectment: they say they own a piece of it 

Ejectment under Chapter 66 comes up when the occupant claims an ownership or equitable interest in the property. Not a right to rent it. A right to it. 

Here is the pattern we see. An owner hits a rough stretch. A friend or a family member helps out, puts money in, covers a mortgage payment, pays for a repair. Later, that person moves in. Later still, the relationship goes sideways and the person says they have an interest in the house because of what they put into it. 

Now the case is not just about who sleeps there. The court has to sort out whether that person gets paid something or simply gets removed. That is a bigger case than the other two, with more discovery, more proof and more time. It is also the case you absolutely do not want to file as a simple eviction, because a simple eviction does not have room in it to decide an ownership claim. 

The two questions that sort almost every one of these 

Question one: was there rent? Not a gift, not gas money once, not help with groceries. An arrangement where the person was paying to live there. If yes, you are probably looking at an eviction. 

Question two: does the occupant claim an interest in the property itself? Are they saying they own part of it, or that they are owed a share because of money they put in? If yes, you are probably looking at an ejectment. 

If the answer to both is no, and the person is simply there with no right and no rent, that is the unlawful detainer lane. Two questions. They do most of the work. 

Three people at the same kitchen table 

The cousin. Came for a week in March, still here in September, never paid a cent, never claimed the house was his. No rent, no ownership claim. That is an unlawful detainer. 

The ex-partner. Not on the lease, not on the deed, moved in two years ago, never paid rent and never claimed to own anything. Same answer. Unlawful detainer, not an eviction, even though it has lasted longer and hurts more. 

The friend. Put $12,000 into a new roof when you could not cover it, moved in eight months later, and now says he owns a piece of the house because of that money. That is an ejectment. The court will have to decide whether he is repaid, whether he holds any interest, and whether he goes. Filing that as an eviction gets you nowhere, slowly. 

No lease does not mean no tenant 

Here is the trap that runs the other direction. An owner assumes that because there is nothing in writing, there is no tenancy, so unlawful detainer must be the answer. Not necessarily. 

If the person has been handing you $400 a month in cash, or covering the power bill every month, or paying something irregularly but consistently toward living there, you may have created a tenancy without meaning to. Oral rental agreements are real in Florida. So are arrangements built out of habit. 

Before you decide, go get your records. Bank deposits, cash app history, texts where money was discussed. What those show may put you in a different chapter than the one you assumed. It is much cheaper to find that out before filing than after. 

What a dismissal actually costs you 

A dismissal is not a procedural annoyance. When someone is living in your property, every week has a price. You are carrying the mortgage, the insurance and the utilities. You cannot rent it, sell it or use it. If you file the wrong action and it gets thrown out, you do not resume where you left off. You go back to the beginning and refile the right case, and the occupant is still there the entire time. 

That is why the diagnosis comes first. The paperwork and the process differ for each of these three, and the differences are not cosmetic. Get the case type right, and the rest of it is work. Get it wrong, and the rest of it is wasted. 

If you are not sure which of the three you have, that is a normal place to be. Bring the facts, not a conclusion: who is there, how they got there, what they have paid you if anything, and whether they have ever claimed to own part of the place. 

If someone is living in your property and you are not sure which case you actually have, book a discovery call with Calarco Law before you file anything. 

Share